The Lord of the Rings: Crusades

The Lord of the Rings: Crusades would be a game for most current systems, and the sequel to Lord of the Rings: Conquest. This is something I've been planning for a while, but forgot about until very recently. For the longest time, I've always been convinced that there should be a video game that accurately captures the feel of a battle between the forces of good and evil in the fantastical Lord of the Rings universe. Conquest, in my opinion, was a step in the right direction, and a good move by Pandemic, the company that made the original Star Wars Battlefront games. However, I still think they could have captured the fantasy atmosphere much better while still maintaining the strategic gameplay elements they were going for.

That's why I decided to make this idea; it would incorporate elements from Star Wars Battlefront, as well as games like Chivalry: Medieval Warfare and the more recent Middle Earth: Shadow of Mordor. My overall goal is to create an outline for a well-balanced tactical medieval battling game, but one that also does justice to its excellent source material.

Story
I've decided that in order to make things more interesting from a story standpoint, this game would delve more into the history of the Lord of the Rings franchise, as it was detailed in the Silmarillion, despite also extending into some of the main series a little bit. I would be interested in telling the tale of the war between the Valar and Melkor, and the fateful battles it encompassed.

This game would have a story involving Melkor returning to try to conquer Arda, the planet on which Middle-Earth is located, and the species of Arda (Elves, Men, and Dwarves) having to team up with the Valar (who are basically the gods of this universe) and the Istari (or wizards, such as Gandalf) to banish him from the mortal plain once again. It should also be noted that this story would be non-canon, similar to Hyrule Warriors, so that there would be maximum creative license and freedom to bring tons of different things from the universe together.

The story would take place during the events of the main trilogy, near the end of the final installment, during the battle of the Black Gate, which would act as the setting for the first level of the game. However, the difference in the outcome of events would be that Sauron wouldn't be destroyed upon the destruction of the One Ring. Instead, the destruction of the ring would send Sauron to the void, which would give Melkor, who is essentially the metaphysical embodiment of evil, the chance to return to Arda at a fraction of his true power, due to an secret enchantment he created with Sauron that would cause them to switch dimensions in case one of them was destroyed.

It should again be noted that this is a non-canon story, and does not interface with the Dagor Dagorath, which is essentially the end of the world in Lord of the Rings that involves Melkor returning. Instead, Melkor would temporarily return to pose a threat to Arda.

Gameplay
The gameplay would take place much like the average shooter or PvP-oriented game: on sizable maps. The combat itself would put priority on responsive and fluid controls, so as not to make the player feel disconnected from the character he/she is playing as.

Battlefields
The layout would have roughly the same as Star Wars Battlefront or even games like Battlefield or Titanfall. Fighting would take place on maps with varying designs, dotted with command posts that dictate how units move about the battlefield. Holding a command post uninterrupted for a certain amount of time will claim it for your team and make it usable as a respawn point. Battlefields would be spacious, but not so large that players end up getting separated from the action, particularly upon dying.

Heroes and Villains
The Lord of the Rings: Conquest had a hero and villain system similar to Star Wars Battlefront II, whereby meeting certain conditions in battle would allow a single player use of a notable, powerful character for a certain amount of time. I would bring back this system, but make it blend more seamlessly with the rest of battle. An objection I had to the system in the other games is that using a hero or villain would feel like it took me to a different game, rather than feeling like a change to a continuous battle. To change things up, I would have the hero and villain characters have unique abilities, but also have weaknesses that would, on the whole, only make them somewhat better that normal units. Unless, of course, you play with them long enough to figure out how to apply their strengths properly in battle.

Melee Combat
Player movement would be controllable at all times, without melee moves carrying the player in a particular direction and disorienting them. However, there would be separate heavy and light attacks, with heavier, more powerful attacks requiring more deliberation. As such, swinging wildly would be an inferior strategy to planning movements according to surroundings. Unlike Lord of the Rings: Conquest, there would also be no system of elaborate combos. Combos would instead be simple, and meant to take opponents by surprise or overpower them, but they'd also expose certain vulnerabilities that could be taken advantage of if the user isn't careful.

Magic
Magic use in this game would be oriented towards area-of-effect attacks, attacks from a short distance, and support, much like in your typical MOBA-type game. This is not to say a wizard character couldn't defend himself at close range, but his close-range abilities are far inferior to those of melee-oriented characters. Powers in a magic user's arsenal would include slow fireballs, lightning bolts, lightning storms, and shields, among others. His or her purpose would be primarily to put enemy groups at a disadvantage to his or her allies, but a wizard on its own could be a niche specialty class.

Ranged Combat
Everybody knows about  Lord of the Rings' s elves, and their legendary mastery of the bow and arrow. There would certainly be a lot of elven goodness in this game's ranged class, along with crossbow users and users of other weapons, such as spears. Much like with every other class, the weapon loadout could be changed, and every ranged weapon would have noticeably different control dynamics, much like in Chivalry. The ranged class would generally be able to operate either from a very long distance or a very close range. Grouping up against it would be a dominating strategy.

Battlefields
This game would have plenty of battlefields to choose from, all of them playable at some point in the main story as well. Some would be larger than others, some would have large rooms, and some would have multiple levels where others don't. There would seriously be something for everybody in their collective design, and hopefully they'd do justice to the various Lord of the Rings locations.

Here's the full list:
 * The Shire
 * Rivendell
 * Fangorn Forest
 * The Westfold
 * Amon Hen
 * The Mines of Moria
 * Udun
 * Sea of Nurnen
 * The Black Gate
 * Erebor
 * Minas Tirith
 * Isengard
 * Pelennor Fields
 * Cirith Ungol
 * Helm's Deep
 * Mirkwood
 * Osgiliath
 * Laketown
 * The Two Trees of Valinor
 * Anfauglith