Thread:Geniusguy445/@comment-26135418-20150312111300

You lamented, in your comments, about there not being a way to find the best stuff: Have you considered setting up a Badge System for idea pages? (Is it even possible?) Instead of the Badges being automatically generated, they could be awarded by Users (not including unidentified Wikia Contributors). So a page could earn several of the same Badges from different Users. For example: An “I Would Play this Game!” Badge could be given by {20} Users. The number is a link to a page showing all of the Idea’s awarded Badges, and who awarded them. (Users can only award a Badge to a page once.)

Like the User Badges, you could have Gold, Silver, and Bronze values awarded. Badge ideas: “Great Original Ideas”, “Great Fanon”, “Good so Far” (indicating the page needs work, but you are interested), “Great Characters”, “Great Artwork”, “Ingenious Gameplay”, and others. Maybe there could also be Copper Badges which give no points but could give the creator an idea about why they are not getting higher rated Badges, like: “Poorly Written”, “I Don’t Understand This”, “Just Roster Changes”, or “Impossible” (like a game that will never be made because of too many licenses involved).

The pages could then be Ranked, like Users (but please show all rankings). For each page the lines could show how many Gold, Silver, Bronze, and Copper Badges the page has been awarded. This is so you could see if a page was ranked low because no one awarded it Badges, or it’s only getting Copper Badges.

I like this idea because it would allow people to say they like a game (and why), without posting another trite comment of praise. 